Helmel Products, Inc.
Coordinate Measuring Machine Product Line

The Checkmaster is a compact manual bench top coordinate measuring machine for production floor or lab.

The Phoenix is a rugged, compact DCC (automatic) coordinate measuring machine suited to production environments.

The Microgage is a very compact high accuracy coordinate measuring machine ideal for production, in-line, and process control applications.

The Microstar series of coordinate measuring machines are traditional moving bridge types constructed with intrinsic mechanical accuracy that guarantees precision derived from the structure without software error mapping.

The Axium is a 4-axis automatic shaft measuring machine suited for crankshaft inspection in production on the factory floor.

Historically coordinate measuring machines, which were also called stylus machines occasionally, have been used for two-dimensional checks and were operated manually.

Since the early 1970s computer driven coordinate measuring machines using electronic touch trigger probes became the standard in the industry.

Today the most common types of coordinate measuring machines are the moving bridge designs.

Both manual and direct computer controlled coordinate measuring machines can produce evaluations to the geometric dimensioning and tolerancing standard.

Feature relationships like angle, distance, perpendicularity or parallelism are measurements that can be performed with a coordinate measuring machine with extreme precision.

For high-volume or large-scale production applications or specialized manufacturing the coordinate measuring machine can be an efficient and repeatable inspection device that allows measurement of any part quickly and automatically.

In the modern fast-paced, highly-competitive manufacturing environment with specific production needs there is an increasing demand for a tough small coordinate measuring machine with inherent protection and simple interfaces for easy access to basic measuring routines without any loss of accuracy.

Specifying Your Coordinate Measuring Machine

The type, shape, size and dimensional tolerance of the part to be inspected determine the kind of equipment to be considered. Flat parts (sheet metal stampings, plastic, rubber, etc.) can be inspected faster with a video system. An optical comparator is likewise a 2-D device, best for checking profiles or small flat parts by hand. They are not suited for production.

Height Gages, as the name implies, are good for checking heights on a surface plate. Inspecting a hole pattern with this 1-D device by flipping the part, still practiced by some, is cumbersome, time consuming and unreliable. In this day and age, when a small Coordinate Measuring Machine does not cost more than some height gages, this is a truly wasteful approach.

For 3-D measurements the Coordinate Measuring Machine should be the equipment of choice. A motorized Coordinate Measuring Machine with a powerful computer and software does cost just a few thousand dollars more today than did a manual Coordinate Measuring Machine of the same size twenty five years ago. They were equipped with a digital readout only. The variety and configuration of sensors available today give the user the possibility to inspect just about any type of part, be it a complex aircraft valve body, a plastic or rubber part, a glass lens or polished mold. Line lasers, capable of taking thousands of points per second can digitize an odd shaped part in minutes.

In short, Coordinate Measuring Machines cover the whole gamut from simple to use manual units with a basic touch probe and software to fully automatic machines in a production environment pre-programmed to inspect the most sophisticated of parts to a fair accuracy. You can have anything in between. Like the survival of the fittest, time has removed inferior designs from the market.

Of the many styles out there the traveling bridge, the gantry and the horizontal arm design are most common with the traveling bridge being the most popular. Horizontal arm units, capable of measuring large envelopes at acceptable accuracies are used mainly for large auto body parts, large weldments, etc.

When selecting a Coordinate Measuring Machine the following issues should be addressed first before looking at accessories: a) size, b) manual or DCC (CNC), c) Inspection room or shop floor application.

a) The size is obviously determined by your largest part.

Then again if this particular part shows up only 2 times a year, you should reconsider. The smaller the unit the better. On the other hand you also have to look at the configuration of the parts. If you have a part that is 12” wide, for instance, with 3” deep bores on either side that you wish to access with an articulating head, you need an additional 5” of travel on each side. This brings the total travel to 22” with no safety clearance added. Pre-qualifying these positions on the reference sphere further adds to the necessary envelope.

b) Manual or DCC.

Financial issues aside, this is largely a function of part quantity or a combination of quantity and complexity. A prototype shop should have a manual unit and a production environment requires a DCC unit. Aside from the fact that CNC units have dramatically come down in price, medium part quantities e.g. 10-30 can be efficiently checked manually with a pre-written program. An unskilled operator then simply touches the points on the part as commanded by the screen. The in and out of tolerance condition may be printed out.

A ROI calculations sheet is available for cross-over quantities making a decision as to manual or DCC easy.

If a part is complex and small, with fine features, a DCC unit is recommended even for small quantities. It is hard to negotiate a .5mm stylus into a 1.5mm hole without breaking it.

c) Shop floor or inspection room application.

Since an inspection room has to cover all eventualities it should be equipped with a fair size unit, the top of the line software offered by the OEM, an indexable probe head (manual or motorized) and a good selection of styli and extensions. This requires a well trained and/or experienced operator. Any new operator should be well trained by the OEM.

When selecting a shop floor Coordinate Measuring Machine robustness of the equipment has to be considered. Mechanical bearing units are inherently more reliable, since they do not require a constant supply of dry and clean air which can create a maintenance headache. Air bearing Coordinate Measuring Machines are a poor choice for applications in a dirty environment, requiring an expensive enclosure that a mechanical bearing unit with covers and bellows can do without. The potential user should educate himself on this issue.

Production Coordinate Measuring Machines are usually dedicated to one or just a few specific parts. Parts should be fixtured. Fixtures can be supplied by the user or the OEM. The same goes for the part programs. Probing systems should be as simple as possible. Motorized probe heads should be avoided in high production situations if the part is not too complex. Probes with detachable stylus modules and a stylus rack may accomplish the same task at half the price if no more than 6-8 orientations are required. Angled styli orientations can be created with stylus knuckles.

Fast start menus make the operation and program selection easy for shop floor personnel.

If the temperature in the shop varies substantially from 68°F (20°C), the standard OEM calibration temperature, you may want to look at a temperature compensation package or purchase a unit with metal scales on metal structures if you inspect metal parts. It is always a good practice to let the part “soak” to reach the same temperature as the Coordinate Measuring Machine.

Sensors

The electronic touch trigger probe, the scanning probe, the single point laser, the line laser and the video camera are the sensors offered on Coordinate Measuring Machines today.

Touch Trigger Probes, being the least expensive yet capable of measuring just about everything on a machined part, are used in the majority of applications. They usually consist of a probe head, fixed or indexable, the touch probe itself and the styli. DCC machines may be outfitted with a motorized indexable head (7 ½°), but add substantially to the overall cost. For a few thousand dollars more you can purchase a small DCC Coordinate Measuring Machine.

Probes with detachable stylus modules are a good investment, especially for DCC units. They allow the use of a stylus rack (6 stalls) akin to a tool changer on a machining center. Modules are held in place magnetically and detach in the event of a collision without damaging the probe itself. A multitude of styli (measuring tips) are available from several sources that cover just about any measuring task, from a .3mm ball tip to a 1” diameter disc to a cylinder for thin sheet metal.

Mechanical Scanning Probes are used to gather a high number of points in bores and surfaces of prismatic parts and for digitizing non-linear unknown surfaces. Higher density points give you a more accurate picture of the feature as required by ANSI 14.5 e.g. roundness, cylindricity and flatness. These probes are obviously more expensive than trigger probes and require a high end controller.

The Single Point Laser is also used for digitizing. It is an excellent tool to check the profile of delicate surfaces e.g. coated optics and soft parts since it does not physically touch the part.

The Line Laser is the fastest way to digitize or inspect non-linear surfaces and contours like cell phone housings or car body parts. The lines are up to 2” wide taking 4000 or more points per second. The accuracies range from + .001” to + .00025”. It is a powerful tool in conjunction with CAD software having a 3-D best fit option. The line laser is popular for reverse engineering.

Video attachments for Coordinate Measuring Machines require additional software and back-lighting and are therefore not widely used.

Software

Measuring software is the most important part of a Coordinate Measuring Machine next to the physical structure. It may be your main purchasing criteria. Most OEM’s have their own brand, some do not. You should inquire as to how long the software has been on the market. It is very hard to evaluate Coordinate Measuring Machine software in just a couple of hours unless you are an experienced Coordinate Measuring Machine operator. The big names in the industry do not necessarily have the easiest to use systems, which is what the buyer should be looking for. Whichever software takes the least number of keystrokes or mouse clicks to measure a feature or a complete part is the better one. Fancy graphics and many windows do not measure a part. If time permits take a somewhat complex part to the vendors and compare inspection and DCC programming time as well as the ease to do so.

Beyond user friendliness you may need other features like real time SPC, export to CAD or a 4th axis.

You should be cautious with the much talked about Coordinate Measuring Machine program writing from CAD. It’s O.K. for simple parts, but a DCC motion program with a motorized head and widely varying styli is fraught with pitfalls. If and when it has progressed to a point where it’s close to being seamless, it would require quite a knowledgeable operator. Most people do not recognize the fact that a Coordinate Measuring Machine is not a simple single point system like a machine tool with only one fixed and defined coordinate system where the part to be machined is always aligned to the axis travels. Therefore a Coordinate Measuring Machine programmer, not necessarily the operator has to have a good grasp of 3-D points in space and coordinate system transformations. Good and thorough training of the programmer is imperative. Once a program is written a lesser trained person may push the buttons. There is many a Coordinate Measuring Machine that sits in a corner because nobody knows how to use it.

When evaluating software you also may inquire about the platform (Windows and C++) and whether there are service contracts with future upgrades available. Proper support is important.

Accuracy

The potential user should understand the difference between resolution, repeatability, and accuracy. In brief; resolution is the least count of the measuring system. Repeatability is how well the Coordinate Measuring Machine repeats a given dimension or feature; this is always some multiple of the resolution and includes the non-repeatability of the probe, which in some instances exceeds that of the Coordinate Measuring Machine itself. Linear accuracy, taken along each axis travel, is how much any linear dimension deviates from the absolute NIST standard. The volumetric accuracy is usually determined with a ball bar according to B89.4.1a or another artifact and includes the non-linearity of the ways, out of squareness condition, length variation of all axes to one another as well as the non-repeatability of the probe. Consequently this number is substantially higher than the linear accuracy.

Some Coordinate Measuring Machines are highly software compensated to achieve the stated accuracy. There is nothing wrong with taking out the last wrinkles of an otherwise sound structure, but making computer compensation more or less the basis of the Coordinate Measuring Machine accuracy is not commendable. If you have a collision, lose the compensation table or upgrade to a better software system down the line, re-mapping the Coordinate Measuring Machine will be expensive. Coordinate Measuring Machines with intrinsic accuracy have the lowest maintenance cost over their life span.